Home > Therapy > How Competent is Your Therapist?

How Competent is Your Therapist?

By: Ian Murnaghan BSc (hons), MSc - Updated: 11 Dec 2012 | comments*Discuss
 
Depression Therapy Therapist Cognitive

Therapy is an important part of depression treatment for many people. It might go hand-in-hand with medication or it could be used with a range of alternative treatments. Most agree though that it can play a pivotal role in helping patients to recover from depression or manage it long-term to prevent a breakdown.

But with all the elements to consider such as the type of therapy, should you question the competence of your therapist? According to a new study, the answer is a resounding yes – at least in the case of cognitive therapy for depression.

Cognitive Therapy and Therapist Competence

In a recent study, it was found that depressed patients showed a more significant improvement in their symptoms if the therapist was shown as more competent. This competence was examined in terms of how closely the therapist followed the guidelines for using cognitive therapy.

Another study finding was that this therapist competence could be the important key in the outcome for the patient as well. In this study, the more competent the therapist, the more the patients showed a reduction in depression symptoms.

Researchers think this mostly applies to people who have major anxiety or a long history of depression, especially where it started at an early age. For those who have less intense and complicated depression, moderately skilled cognitive therapists can still help.

Cognitive Therapy Scale

Researchers used a tool called the Cognitive Therapy Scale. It is also used by an organisation that accredits cognitive therapists.

The scale works by rating therapists on many different skills that are important to success as a cognitive therapist. This includes skills relating to interpersonal relations as well as the many different techniques that are believed to help depressed patients.

Rating Therapist Competence in Cognitive Therapy

In this particular study, researchers rated the competence of the therapists during the first four sessions for sixty different patients. They also had patients fill out a survey that helped to measure their level of depression.

To assess the effect of competence on depression, the researchers compared the competence scores with the depression levels they measured in patients. They found that the patients who had really high anxiety and depression showed the most benefit from the very competent therapists.

Long-term results after a couple of months showed the same benefit but not quite as strong. It seems that early on in therapy is where patient outcomes are more strongly related to therapist competence.

Choosing the Right Therapist

It may seem like the obvious choice when it comes to cognitive therapy – use a competent therapist. But there are many well-intentioned, qualified therapists who aren’t necessarily the highly competent, experienced ones we would expect. Such therapists can still do much to benefit depressed patients.

If, however, you do have more complicated or severe depression, then it is probably wise to find out as much as possible about your therapist’s training and experience. Where patient outcomes have more at stake, this competence can make a big difference in helping a person to overcome depression.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Mandy
    Re: Depression Due to Bereavement
    I just lost my husband hollween morning heart attack in main bedroom and died I was his career ,wife,nurse,over 20years together…
    11 December 2018
  • tra
    Re: What Support is There For Long Term Depression Sufferer?
    I'm a 30 + woman who keeps on a brave face but suffers in silence since my mother attempted…
    6 October 2018
  • Sammy
    Re: How to Rebuild Your Life After a Breakdown
    I'm 32 and have had severe depression, insomnia, HF autism and adhd my entire life. I had some help as a…
    29 September 2018
  • Dsmit
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    After 8 years by myself after an emotionally exhausting relationship I eventually reconnected with the love of my life that I had…
    28 September 2018
  • Dsmit
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    After 8 years by myself after an emotionally exhausting relationship I eventually reconnected with the love of my life that I had…
    28 September 2018
  • NYC93
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    I had an abortion a few months ago. June of this year to be exact. I felt it was the right thing to do because me and my boyfriend…
    19 September 2018
  • OvercomeDepression
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    Swte - Your Question:I had a medical abortion at 8 weeks in April. I was one minute okay afterwards then down the next , but now…
    13 August 2018
  • Swte
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    I had a medical abortion at 8 weeks in April. I was one minute okay afterwards then down the next , but now August .( Especially…
    12 August 2018
  • CoralReef
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    I had an abortion 7 months ago, it was the right thing to do. I had only been with my boyfriend for 3 months, we both live at home…
    26 June 2018
  • Blossom
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    I'm 17 and had a surgical abortion last Tuesday (15th May 2018) at 12 weeks pregnanto. Ithe was completely unplanned so I…
    24 May 2018