Home > Depression Issues > Controversial New Brain Treatment for Depression

Controversial New Brain Treatment for Depression

By: Ian Murnaghan BSc (hons), MSc - Updated: 6 Sep 2012 | comments*Discuss
Depression Brain Treatment Controversial

A new brain treatment for depression has stirred up a great deal of controversy when it was approved. The treatment is non-invasive and utilises a magnetic device that stimulates a depressed person's brain. The unique device works by transmitting magnetic pulses through the person's skull.

Unresponsive Depression

The treatment is aimed at depressed people who have been unresponsive to conventional depression therapies. These include antidepressants and a number of other therapies. The new therapy is known as Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) and is believed to be relatively low risk in comparison with other invasive procedures such as implanting electrodes in a patient or administering Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT).

The treatment is one that can only be provided upon the provision of a prescription by a physician and is intended for people with severe clinical depression. For a patient to receive the therapy, they must have previously tried drug therapy and other forms of depression therapy such as psychotherapy.

Positive Research Findings

The device was approved because of a study that looked at TMS and compared it to a 'placebo' device. Patients who received treatment from TMS showed improvement versus those who received treatment from the other device. The study was also considered accurate and reputable because not only did patients not know who received the real device, but neither did the doctors nor the researchers who rated the level of depression after the treatment.

Controversy in TMS

Still, the treatment is considered controversial, mostly because it is directed right at the brain and these kinds of treatments tend to raise many questions. One criticism from other researchers has been that a patient can tell if they are receiving a real treatment or a 'bogus' one, which would sway the study results to favour the new device.

There is, however, another clinical study trial underway to investigate the effectiveness of TMS. Hopefully, the results will be similarly positive and will show a low-risk profile for the device.

Understanding TMS

TMS works by stimulating the brain's nerve cells but it does so externally rather than inside the body. Given that it does not require surgery, it is considered non-invasive and also non-systemic because it does not enter the bloodstream.

The magnetic pulses are directed at the area of the brain that is thought to influence depression and mood. A patient doesn't require sedation or anaesthesia, which is another reason the treatment is considered to be low-risk, particularly in comparison with other depression treatments that have significant side-effects. In fact, the entire procedure for TMS lasts for approximately forty minutes and it is performed on an outpatient basis, usually in the office of a psychiatrist.

A patient will receive TMS daily for a period of four to six weeks although the downside is that the treatment is extremely expensive. Still, despite the controversy of it being a brain treatment, the new therapy is exciting news for depression patients who have seemingly tried every other treatment but with no success. The low risk of side-effects means that patients can feel more comfortable receiving treatment.

Improving Outcomes for Depression

While there is still much research needed on TMS, for now it can be viewed as a positive treatment in that it provides hope for people who have unsuccessfully tried other standard treatments for depression. Suffering from depression is devastating and the need for new, effective treatments is important to restoring happiness and balance to the lives of millions of Britons who suffer from the condition.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • OvercomeDepression
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    ED - Your Question:I've just turned 25 and I've had 2 abortions. I also have a son who is 3. And is the most amazing person in my…
    14 November 2017
  • OvercomeDepression
    Re: Insomnia Caused by Depression
    corey - Your Question:Hello and im corey and im 40 years old. Ive been experiencing sleep difficulties for the past 2 weeks. To…
    23 October 2017
  • corey
    Re: Insomnia Caused by Depression
    Hello and im corey and im 40 years old. Ive been experiencing sleep difficulties for the past 2 weeks. To this day Im unable to…
    20 October 2017
  • Laura
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    I had medical abortion a Week ago today. Feeling very emotional ?? and anxious ?? got to go back to Hospital in 3 days for…
    17 October 2017
  • Rosey
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    Hi, I had an abortion at 13 weeks and it was fifteen weeks ago I thought it was my only decision and it's the biggest regret of my…
    12 October 2017
  • OvercomeDepression
    Re: Avoiding Negative and Thinking Positive Thoughts
    Bix - Your Question:What do you do when depression floors you so bad that you feel you cant talk? It has…
    2 October 2017
  • Bix
    Re: Avoiding Negative and Thinking Positive Thoughts
    What do you do when depression floors you so bad that you feel you cant talk? It has left my mind blank…
    30 September 2017
  • OvercomeDepression
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    J - Your Question:I didn't have an abortion yet but I'm going soon. I just found out that I'm pregnant with my boyfriend of 7…
    25 September 2017
  • Not Fine
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    I had a medical abortion in March 2017 at 20 weeks pregnancy due to genetic issues in the foetus. My first child (10 yrs old now)…
    15 September 2017
  • OvercomeDepression
    Re: Depression After an Abortion
    :-( - Your Question:I had a surgical abortion 10 weeks ago I would of been 16 weeks pregnant this week. I am heartbroken at what…
    15 September 2017
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the OvercomeDepression website. Please read our Disclaimer.